Commons:Closed most valued reviews/2008/07

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to: navigation, search

Head of a dragonfly (with legends)[edit]

   
Head dragonfly legends 1.jpg
View
Nominated by:
Alvesgaspar on 2008-03-29 16:12 (UTC)
Scope:
head of a dragonfly

Previous reviews

  • Pictogram voting question.svg Question Commons:Valued image candidates/Head dragonfly legends.jpg 1. Why both? Rocket000 (talk) 21:33, 12 June 2008 (UTC)
    • You may get a hint by looking at the previous review? It is a question of the ability to localize to other languages. My proposal was actually to have it as an SVG(!) with an embedded bitmap of have vector line drawing lengends prepared for localization to other languages. That would make the image more valuable as making a derived, e.g., Hindu version from the English one would be easy. The poor mans solution is to have numbered legends and then have the labels in the image page. -- Slaunger (talk) 21:40, 12 June 2008 (UTC)
      • Ah, ok. The SVG overlay is a good idea (cases like this are the only times there should ever be bitmaps in SVG!). Rocket000 (talk) 03:07, 13 June 2008 (UTC)
      • There was a little naming conflict, let's stick to using the actual name of the image. Now my comment's confusing. Rocket000 (talk) 03:42, 13 June 2008 (UTC)
MVR Scores:
Head dragonfly legends 1.jpg: 0 <--
Head dragonfly legends.jpg: 0
=>
Image:Head dragonfly legends 1.jpg: Undecided <--
Image:Head dragonfly legends.jpg: Undecided
-- Slaunger (talk) 19:46, 10 July 2008 (UTC)
Voting is closed. Await automatic removal by VICbot at 0:18 or 12:18 (UTC)
Head dragonfly legends.jpg
View
Nominated by:
Alvesgaspar on 2008-06-05 09:26 (UTC)
Scope:
head of a dragonfly
  • Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment Antenna is spelled wrong. – flamurai 17:11, 5 June 2008 (UTC)
MVR Scores:
Head dragonfly legends 1.jpg: 0
Head dragonfly legends.jpg: 0 <--
=>
Image:Head dragonfly legends 1.jpg: Undecided
Image:Head dragonfly legends.jpg: Undecided <--
-- Slaunger (talk) 19:46, 10 July 2008 (UTC)
Voting is closed. Await automatic removal by VICbot at 0:18 or 12:18 (UTC)

Edward VI of England[edit]

   
Edward VI of England c. 1546.jpg
View
Nominated by:
PKM on 2008-06-09 02:06 (UTC)
Scope:
Edward VI of England
Used in:
en:Edward VI of England, en:1500-1550 in fashion, en:Henry VIII of England, en:Tudor dynasty, various portals and galleries
  • Symbol neutral vote.svg Neutral My concern here is that this illustrates Edward VI as Prince of Wales, not as King of England. Thus, to nitpick, it depicts "Edward, Prince of Wales" rather than "Edward VI of England". I'm not sure if this is something we should concern ourselves with, so I am opening an MVR between this and Image:Edward VI Scrots c1550.jpg. – flamurai 02:35, 9 June 2008 (UTC)
MVR Scores:
Edward VI of England c. 1546.jpg: 0 <--
Edward VI Scrots c1550.jpg: -1
=>
Image:Edward VI of England c. 1546.jpg: Undecided <--
Image:Edward VI Scrots c1550.jpg: Undecided
-- Slaunger (talk) 19:50, 10 July 2008 (UTC)
Voting is closed. Await automatic removal by VICbot at 0:18 or 12:18 (UTC)
Edward VI Scrots c1550.jpg
View
Nominated by:
– flamurai on 2008-06-09 02:37 (UTC)
Scope:
Edward VI of England
Used in:
Edward VI of England et al.

Symbol oppose vote.svg Oppose A copyvio I am afraid, as this was scanned from a UK book. I have nominated for deletion. --MichaelMaggs 13:55, 9 June 2008 (UTC)

Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment I have changed the license from PD-art to PD-old, and under PD-old I don't believe this is proved copyvio. The instructions on the PD-art tag say that the UK would likely support the photographer's rights, but that has not been demonstrated. We set a very dangerous precedent for the quality of our art coverage if we assume that any image scanned from a UK book is disallowed. I will also look for a US publication with the same image (I think I have one). - PKM 16:37, 9 June 2008 (UTC)

MVR Scores:
Edward VI of England c. 1546.jpg: 0
Edward VI Scrots c1550.jpg: -1 <--
=>
Image:Edward VI of England c. 1546.jpg: Undecided
Image:Edward VI Scrots c1550.jpg: Undecided <--
-- Slaunger (talk) 19:50, 10 July 2008 (UTC)
Voting is closed. Await automatic removal by VICbot at 0:18 or 12:18 (UTC)