File talk:Internet blackholes.svg

meaning of categories

The meaning of "under surveillance" etc. is not at all clear. 134.91.141.112 09:55, 18 February 2010 (UTC)

Misleading legend

I agree with the above comment and I go further: the labels "under surveillance" and "heavy surveillance" are misleading. "Under surveillance", as used by the original source, means that the country is under surveillance by Reporters Without Borders. The term "heavy surveillance" is not found anywhere on the Reporters Without Borders website, and its use strongly and improperly suggests that, in the countries classified as "under surveillance", the internet users are the ones being surveilled. The "under surveillance" should probably be changed or clarified, but most importantly, "heavy surveillance" needs to be changed to something that does not imply any connection with "under surveillance". Ortsz (talk) 05:28, 25 September 2010 (UTC)

And most of the non-English versions of the legend also appear to need changing for the same reason. Ortsz (talk) 05:37, 25 September 2010 (UTC)

This file has been used in: Jan Theofel (2009-07-18). Wir sind nicht alleine: Internetzensur weltweit (in de). Retrieved on 2010-12-30.

source?

Where is the Reporters Without Borders original source and definitions of the different levels of surveillance? As long as the terms used are not defined properly, I don't see much value in this world map.

Original Research

This work seems to be an original research reflecting an user Point of view. The map is not published by any source. RSF does not provide a such map. Some states status are very strange or obviously false.

Travail inédit

Cette carte semble être un travail inédit reflétant le point de vue de ses auteurs. La carte n'est publiée par aucune source fiable. RSF ne fournie pas une telle carte. Les appréciations de certains états semblent fantaisistes voire totalement faux.

Fuente primaria

Este trabajo parece ser una trabajo original, una fuente primaria que refleja el punto de vista de sus autores. El mapa no esta publicado por cualquier otra fuente. RSF no publica un tal mapa. Las apreciaciones de unos estados son fantasiosas o obviamente falsas. Vatekor (talk) 11:33, 15 October 2011 (UTC)

Germany

I think Germany is no longer censoring since late 2011, since the Zugangserschwerungsgesetz was stopped. --Conspi^ration 22:18, 23 August 2012 (UTC)