User talk:Gmaxwell/edisoncats

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to: navigation, search

Scheme[edit]

I've created Category:Phonograph cylinder recordings. I'm not sure if Edison cylinder recordings should be a subcategory of it or not, but we will want a way to identify all of the files from this source, I imagine. If we do create something like Category:Edison cylinder recordings, Category:Edison brown wax series, Category:Edison gold moulded process, Category:Edison Blue Amberol Concert Record, and perhaps some others should probably be subcategories of it.

We should also probably decide whether to dump, for example 1910 recordings into Category:1910 or create Category:1910 songs, following the example at en:. I imagine that there would be arguments for and against either approach. Jkelly 17:28, 30 March 2007 (UTC)


Status[edit]

It seems a shame to leave this half-done... we should think about finding other people to help out. Jkelly 18:00, 6 October 2007 (UTC)

Composer/Performer Vangucci[edit]

I am keen to identify this Vangucci. There is a Vangucci mentioned on another Edison list in the New York Military Band. I also have a relation Allessandro Vangucci who was a musician/composer who lived in England on leaving Italy. He lived between c1845 and 1909