Category talk:Desideria of Sweden

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to: navigation, search

Category pages not encyclopedic[edit]

I edited the intro text here today because of WC policy that category pages can have a brief description of a category's contents, and necessary clarifications of it, but should not contain any excessive information which belongs in WP articles. There was more genealogy here than what would seem to be OK for a page like this. EmilEikS (talk) 15:51, 12 July 2009 (UTC)

A proposal: This is Commons:Village_pump. Take these examples or only this [1] and ask them, whether it was a good idea to delete the Desirée Clary wiki. Good luck 21:19, 12 July 2009 (UTC)
Thank you for this constructive proposal which I am moving to the discussion page of that queen (done here now). The matter doesn't concern a good idea, though. It concerns following the rules that already have been determined and set up for us to follow. I have made no change at all to the gallery page you linked to (Desirée Clary), only to the category page (this one). If you would like to raise that question at the pump, you may go ahead do so. If so refer to it from here, please! EmilEikS (talk)