Commons:Wiki Loves Monuments 2023/Juries
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
WLM 2023 | Participating countries | Uploaded images | Organizers | FAQ | Help desk | For organizers |
Subpage for Wiki Loves Monuments 2023 organizers. |
Instructions for local organizers | Knowledge Exchange | Landing pages | CentralNotice | Upload campaigns | Lists of monuments | Overview of monuments | Juries | Tools | Winners |
![]() | For transparency, it is mandatory for national organizers to publish their jury rounds and respective jurors at the earliest possible, ideally before the jury begins. Please see the example below. Also, you don't need to publish all the rounds at once - it can be updated as things progress. |
Bolivia
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Caleidoscopic
Round 1
[edit]- Purpose: Initial filtration
- Jurors:
- Username Caleidoscopic
- Username User:Carlillasa
- Username User:MikaDeViacha
- Username User:NairaWM BO
- Username User:Vanett Graneros
Round 2
[edit]- Purpose: To decide the top 100
- Jurors:
- Username User:Caleidoscopic
- Username User:Carlillasa
- Username User:MikaDeViacha
- Username User:NairaWM BO
- Username User:Vanett Graneros
Round 3 (Final)
[edit]- Purpose: To decide the top 15
- Jurors:
- Username User:Almatunante
- Username User:Beniciachavez
- Username User:Lalibellefotografia
Italy
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Dario Crespi (WMIT)
Round 1
[edit]Religious Buildings
[edit]- Purpose: Intial filtration
- Jurors:
- 7NonnaAndreaLollo7
- Accorra1984
- Adert
- Alefruzzetti
- Aleminnella
- AlMo18
- Angelapre
- Angelesbriones
- Anisa Kuci (WMIT)
- Antonio Lombardini
- Antorkio
- Beatrice
- Cegorle
- Ddany86
- Dejsyuliet
- Dutur
- EL71
- Elemar (WMIT)
- EnveR
- Ettorre
- Ferdi2005
- Filippof
- Francapan
- Francesca Lissoni (WMIT)
- FrangeCe
- Galessandroni
- Giaccai
- Giovamic
- Giu119
- Giuliateruzzi94
- GiuRed
- Giutorcasio
- Gre90
- Hitrandil
- Iosonosempreio
- Jessica91pungitore
- Knopfler61
- Lamarmora55
- LiaFla
- LIL.PAOLO
- Lucarelli Carlo
- Marcok
- Marta Arosio (WMIT)
- Marta Trullu
- MORE55BEL
- NalaRome
- Nessunovuoleessererobi
- Nickdit
- Paolotacchi
- Patriziapuc
- Sabas88
- Sette-quattro
- Silvia.comm
- Spinoziano
- Superchilum
- Tartarugarovesciata
- Valeda73
- Valeriamenchetelli
- Yiyi
- Ysogo
Other Monuments
[edit]- Purpose: Intial filtration
- AndreaOvo
- Archeolucia
- Cloemy
- Cri123stella
- Elitre
- EnveR
- Floflina
- Fontanalice
- Francesca Lissoni (WMIT)
- FraStar
- G.prof
- HeavenMI
- Ilaria Diterlizzi (WMIT)
- Jaja7
- Libera rb
- Malipietceen
- Marcok
- Marta Arosio (WMIT)
- Matteotarzia
- Mattia Colombooo
- Mirifranci
- MsCompliance
- Paolo Bini
- Pattafyx
- Ri4tito
- Ruthven
- Sgiacopo
- Sottobosco90
- SWT666
- Valentina
- Valerio Bozzolan
- Yiyi
- Ysogo
- Ziasil5
Round 2
[edit]Religious Buildings
[edit]- Purpose: To decide the top ~150
- Jurors:
- ...
Other Monuments
[edit]- Purpose: To decide the top ~100
- Jurors:
- ...
Round 3 (Final)
[edit]- Purpose: To decide the top 20
- Jurors:
- ...
Malta
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Toni Sant
Jurors
[edit]Norway
[edit]- Facilitators: Elisabeth Carrera (WMNO) and Jon Harald Søby (WMNO)
Round 1, 2 and 3
[edit]- Purpose: yes/no, ranking, ranking
- Jurors:
- Andreas Vartdal
- Kjersti Lie
- Kjetil Ree
- Nora Konstanse Hansen, The Norwegian Federation of Cultural Heritage Organisations
- Per Roger Lauritzen, The Norwegian Automobile Federation
- Sigrun Espe
Poland
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Jacek Broda (WMPL)
Round 1 i 2
[edit]- Purpose: Intial filtration
- Jurors:
Round 3 i 4
[edit]- Purpose: yes/no, rating
- Jurors:
Sint Eustatius
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Vanessa Rouse
Round 1
[edit]To decide top 10
- Jurors:
- Wolter Braamhorst
- Granville Hassell
- Jacquil Pandt
Suriname
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Rachel, Jennifer, Michelle (WMNL)
Round 1
[edit]- Purpose: Intial filtration; technical quality
- Jurors:
Round 2
[edit]- Purpose: Veto round - filtering out problematic submissions
- Jurors:
Round 3 (Final)
[edit]- Purpose: To decide the top 10
- Jurors:
Sweden
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Axel Pettersson (WMSE)
Round 1, 2 and 3
[edit]- Purpose: yes/no, rating, ranking
- Jurors:
- Per Hasselberg, Board member, Wikimedia Sverige
- Helena Törnqvist, Arbetets museum
- Johanna Murray, Svenska turistföreningen
- Josefine Hellroth Larsson, gemenskapen
Belgium
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: Geertivp
Round 1, 2 and 3
[edit]- Purpose: yes/no, rating, ranking
- Jurors:
Brazil
[edit]- Jury organizer/coordinator: EPorto (WMB)
- Jury tool: Montage
Pre-selection round
[edit]- Purpose: Initial filtration to minimize the number of photos to the final jury
- Number of images: 8208
- Type of round: Yes/No
- Criteria: Receive a "Yes" from at least 1 judge
- Notes: Images contributed by the judges, staff members of Wiki Movement Brazil and images out of scope do not participate in any selection.
- Selection of Images: Images from Wiki Loves Monuments 2023 in Brazil - Pre-selection Round
- Start: 2022-10-09
- End: 2022-10-20
- Jurors:
Round 1
[edit]- Purpose: Filtration of the images that should go to the next round. Minimize the number of images
- Number of images: 1885
- Type of round: Yes/No
- Criteria: Receive a "Yes" from at least two judges
- Notes: This round included all images that received at least 1 "Yes" on the pre-selection round
- Selection of Images: Images from Wiki Loves Monuments 2023 in Brazil - First Round
- Start: 2022-10-23
- End: 2022-10-25
- Jurors:
Round 2
[edit]- Purpose: Evaluate the images under the criteria of beauty, technical quality and visual/social impact of the image and/or the monument depicted.
- Number of images: 296
- Type of round: Rating
- Criteria: Receive an average (3 judges) score of 7.5;
- Notes: This round included all images that received at least 2 "Yes" on round 1
- Selection of Images: Images from Wiki Loves Monuments 2023 in Brazil - Second Round
- Start: 2022-10-25
- End: 2022-10-27
- Jurors:
Round 3
[edit]- Purpose: Evaluate the best images under the criteria of beauty, technical quality and visual/social impact of the image and/or the monument depicted.
- Number of images: 70
- Type of round: Ranking
- Criteria:
- Not repeat at least the five first positions;
- Diversify the types of monuments depicted.
- Notes: This round included all images that received an score of 12 stars combined (3 judges) on round 2
- Selection of Images: Images from Wiki Loves Monuments 2023 in Brazil - Third Round
- Start: 2022-10-27
- End: 2022-10-27
- Jurors:
UAE
[edit]- Jury coordinator: Akbarali
Round 3
[edit]- Purpose: Top 3 winners
- Jurors:
- Username Faisal
- Username Abdu Nasar
- Username Sajjad