Commons talk:Featured picture candidates

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Livioandronico2013 aka Σπάρτακος aka Architas cheating at FPC[edit]

Here we go again... Category:Sockpuppets of Livioandronico2013. --Cart (talk) 17:55, 1 October 2018 (UTC)

Very sad. One thing, however, I find strange: the account "Σπάρτακος" was registered 21 May 2013, which is even earlier than Livioandronico (August 2013). They also uploaded some self-made pictures at the same time Livioandronico was active (long before the known problems with him). This is rather untypical for an egocentric person like Livioandronico. I guess, either the sockpuppetry was planned long-time in advance (for whatever reason), or the account "Σπάρτακος" originally belonged to a different person (possibly his wife/grandmother/whoever) and then, after indefblocking of the main account, the other one was taken over and real sockpuppetry had begun. Whatever may apply -- I hope that his indef block is now truly infinite. Thanks to Cart for fixing the noms. --A.Savin 18:37, 1 October 2018 (UTC) P.S. With the other sock (Architas), all is quite clear -- registered in 2018, uploaded some Italy photos similar to Livio's, with removed EXIF data. --A.Savin 18:39, 1 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment There was really an attempt to game the system, so I would agree about "forfeiting" nominations where cheating took place. I should say that the success rate is very low. But I wonder what would happen to Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:NSG Rotwildpark Stuttgart 2014 14 Bärenschlössle.jpg without the oppose votes. Regards, Yann (talk) 11:39, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
    • I assume that the high rate of double voting, even when it made no difference, was just a way to hide what was going on. An awful lot of work to go to just to get some extra gold stars or extra revenge opposes. Wrt that image, see my comment below about nominators should feel free to renominate if they think the vote was harmed. -- Colin (talk) 11:54, 3 October 2018 (UTC)

Fixing the damage[edit]

I'm slowly looking through contributions for Σπάρτακος on FPC to find nominations where both Livioandronico2013 and Σπάρτακος voted. So far I have only done from Feb to May 2015 and have uncovered many double votes. I'm listing them below. They will all need correcting and there will be some casualties. Clearly the second vote should be removed to correct the score. What do people think about Livioandronico2013's own nominations where he cheated with the Σπάρτακος account? I inclined to think those should be disqualified regardless of the voting outcome. -- Colin (talk) 07:53, 2 October 2018 (UTC)

Tempting as it may seem with all the mess we now have to sort out, I think such disqualifications would set a bad precedent for future cases. It may be hard to know where to draw the line for such actions. --Cart (talk) 11:27, 2 October 2018 (UTC)
Previously our approach was just to remove the sock votes and recount. Perhaps being blocked is bad enough consequence. I don't think we should let "slippery slope" worry us about drawing the line at a certain point if the community agrees. It seems a reasonable position to take that if you cheat in your nomination then it is forfeit. It would be a good disincentive for future cases. This case is far worse than the previous one, with nearly all of Σπάρτακος's contributions at FPC being subsequent duplicate votes of Livioandronico2013 and a large number concerning their own nominations. -- Colin (talk) 12:07, 2 October 2018 (UTC)
Well, if I guess correctly that Σπάρτακος had belonged to an other person before Livioandronico's indefblock, there's formally nothing wrong with their votes at that period of time (ethically, meatpuppetry and friendly votes are still dubious, but that's not relevant here). --A.Savin 13:11, 2 October 2018 (UTC)
Although the CU tool obviously cannot see the person behind an account, and thus often cannot distinguish between meat- and sockpuppetry, behavioural evidence here strongly suggests Livioandronico2013 and Σπάρτακος are indeed one person rather than two people editing in coordination. For example: note the distinctive "+image" edit summary (Livioandronico2013: [1][2][3]; Σπάρτακος: [4][5][6]) I reference this "tell" openly because it is a practice they have discontinued; there are, of course, many others. Эlcobbola talk 15:34, 2 October 2018 (UTC)
We sould disqualify at least when the double votes changed the result. Not sure about the others. Regards, Yann (talk) 06:09, 3 October 2018 (UTC)

I've finished comparing their FPC voting and uncovered 336 nominations where Livioandronico2013 socked to get double the votes. Naturally, quite a lot of them are Livioandronico2013's own photos and/or nominations. I haven't amended any nominations yet. Hopefully some more people will voice their opinions on what we should do with them. There's a strange gap in the contributions from Σπάρτακος between 26 February 2016 and 28 January 2018. Livioandronico2013 got indef blocked in November 2017. The Architas account started on 29 April 2018. This leaves me suspicious there may be another sock account used while Σπάρτακος was dormant. -- Colin (talk) 22:31, 2 October 2018 (UTC)

  • Thinking about it, Σπάρτακος stopped editing shortly after I accused him of meatpuppetry with Livioandronico2013. So I guess he got scared he'd be discovered. Still, there remains the possibility that there are other accounts he used instead. Σπάρτακος only returned when the Livioandronico2013 was blocked indef. -- Colin (talk) 07:35, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Thank you Colin for all your hard work in tracking down all of these double votes. I think we could at least start with fixing the double votes on the third party nominations while waiting for a decision about how to treat all Livioandronico2013/Σπάρτακος nominations. After they are done they could be marked as fixed in the list. I have done so on the second list. Please revert if you don't agree with this way of marking them. --Cart (talk) 08:39, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • That's one approach. Alternatively we could just wait for some more comments. It is quite a big list, so I wouldn't want to have to go through it twice. -- Colin (talk) 09:11, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Ok, let's wait a bit longer before we start the real cleanup work. Of course I'll help with this. --Cart (talk) 09:18, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment I removed some votes where the nominations were not closed yet. --Yann (talk) 06:02, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • On previous cases we have only removed the excess vote(s), per the "one vote per user" rule. With your edits both votes are now removed and you have explained this with "banned user". Is this really correctly done? Should we remove votes because a user is banned too, or is this just in this special case where this is one more sock? Otherwise it would give us a lot of work cleaning up all old votes from banned users. Let's not go wild on this. --Cart (talk) 08:29, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Well, technically neither account is "banned", just indef blocked. I think Yann is removing votes made by the sock while block-evading, rather than retrospectively removing all votes made by the sock. I think that is a reasonable position to take. Part of the reason Livio was blocked was revenge-voting and so permitting him to vote with a block-evading-sock would be wrong, even if that was the only vote made on a nomination by this person. So I would be in favour of removing all votes made by the two sock accounts during the periods where Livio was blocked (the current period and the previous term that was ended by INC against community consensus). Livio was not permitted to edit here during that time, so I think we should not permit votes during that time that were made by block-evading socks. If we allowed them, then we are in effect making the block worthless. Does Yann think we should remove the votes for completed nominations as well as the current ones? -- Colin (talk) 09:11, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Yes, exactly. If we accept votes from indetected socks, that will encourage him (and other LTAs) to sock again.
  • We should also removed votes in closed nominations if they changed the result. In these cases, I would renominate the files for a cleaning process.
  • For other cases, I am quite neutral. I am not against removing them, but I won't push for doing that either. Regards, Yann (talk) 09:59, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Ok, so if I'm reading this right, all votes by Architas's should be removed as well as Σπάρτακος's votes during the time the Architas account was active. In the case of Livioandronico2013/Σπάρτακος double votes, should we remove both votes too or just one of them? --Cart (talk) 10:16, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • I think, regardless of what we decide to do about votes, if a nomination would therefore succeed then it should be automatically promoted without fuss. If it would therefore fail then we should list it here and ping the nominator/creator to see if they want to nominate again, except of course for cases where Livio's nominations fail. I think it reasonable to examine the votes made by Livo while blocked and using a sock account. I can provide a list. It would include all of Architas votes but only some of Σπάρτακος's. We can decide if we want to remove them. I'm not keen to remove all of Σπάρτακος's votes solely because they are a sock, because many were made while Livio was not blocked and he was then entitled to one vote. Even if removing votes doesn't change the outcome to a nomination, if a nominator/creator feels their nomination was damaged by Livio's voting, then I'd be happy to consider that a valid reason to renominate. -- Colin (talk) 10:27, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • I am making a list of FPs where the result was changed by double voting. There are also nominations with one vote support, and one oppose: Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Prowincja Ararat, Widok na Wielki Ararat i klasztor Chor Wirap (04).jpg, Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Bernardo alle Terme - ceiling.jpg, Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dülmen, Hausdülmen, Kettbach -- 2015 -- 8499-503.jpg. Yann (talk) 10:32, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Simplest method would be to strike the second vote, which ever one that is. I think Livio mostly voted first then Σπάρτακος, but occasionally Σπάρτακος was early, or was even the nominator. -- Colin (talk) 10:41, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
  • We all talk about this as Livio's account and socks, but technically the Σπάρτακος account was created first (2013-05-21) and the sock Livioandronico2013 came later (2013-08-23). Whatever. --Cart (talk) 10:48, 3 October 2018 (UTC)
Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment I reviewed all nominations. There are 26 of them were the double votes changed the result. So these FP status should be removed. I am going to renominate some of them. Regards, Yann (talk) 12:47, 4 October 2018 (UTC)

Double Voting Lists[edit]

Livioandronico2013 and Σπάρτακος
  1. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Leitura by José Ferraz de Almeida Júnior 1892.jpg/2
  2. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Concattedrale of Sutri - intern.jpg
  3. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Lądek-Zdrój, Zakład przyrodoleczniczy Wojciech HDR.jpg
  4. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Tsjuder, Jan-Erik „Nag“ Romøren at Party.San Metal Open Air 2013.jpg
  5. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jesus Christ of Gian Lorenzo Bernini in San Sebastiano fuori le mura (Rome).jpg
  6. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Doña Isabel Cobos de Porc by Francisco Goya.jpg
  7. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2015 Wieża widokowa na Borówkowej 01.jpg
  8. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Intern of Church of San Francesco in Amelia.jpg
  9. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:G. Dury - Portrait of Dom Augusto, Duke of Leuchtenberg - Google Art Project.jpg
  10. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Symbol and statues in St. Peter.jpg/2
  11. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Cathédrale Saint-Pierre de Montpellier 02.jpg
  12. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Copenhagen Opera House 2014 05.jpg
  13. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bolma girgyllus 01.JPG
  14. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Hoila-Cider from Zingerle, Bolzano, South Tyrol 0633.jpg
  15. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:15-02-27-Flug-Berlin-Düsseldorf-RalfR-DSCF2427b-02.jpg
  16. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:File:Discobolus in National Roman Museum Palazzo Massimo alle Terme.JPG
  17. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Leighton-Stitching the Standard.jpg
  18. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Prowincja Ararat, Widok na Wielki Ararat i klasztor Chor Wirap (04).jpg
  19. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Southern sea lion, L'Oceanogràfic (1).jpg
  20. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Bernardo alle Terme - ceiling.jpg
  21. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Solidago rugosa 001.JPG
  22. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Tarnobrzeg, kościół Wniebowzięcia NMP, 52.JPG
  23. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Naqsh-e Jahan Square by Pascal Coste 1 edited.jpg
  24. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Catedral de Salisbury, Salisbury, Inglaterra, 2014-08-12, DD 49.JPG
  25. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Regent Street 01.jpg
  26. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Intern of St. George in Locorotondo.jpg
  27. Commons:Featured picture candidates/Image:Junglefowl on tree.jpg
  28. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014-12-18 Fortuna, Johannes Benk at Neue Burg, Vienna -hu- 6224.jpg
  29. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Croatia Opatija Women with dove BW 2014-10-10 10-35-13.jpg
  30. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Keble College Chapel Interior 1, Oxford, UK - Diliff.jpg
  31. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Den Haag Centraal-1589.jpg
  32. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stift Melk Kolomanisaal Deckenfresko 02.JPG
  33. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ljungdalen April 2015 12.jpg
  34. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Trastevere - Chapel ceiling.jpg
  35. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Cupola of Basilica San Vitale (Ravenna).JPG
  36. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2015 Kwiatostan wiśni pospolitej.jpg
  37. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ascension of Jesus among the apostles and the Virgin.jpg
  38. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2015 Kwiatostan gruszy pospolitej.jpg
  39. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Reims Cathedral Organ, France - Diliff.jpg
  40. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:La Joven Madre 1889 by Arturo Michelena.jpg/2
  41. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mary Garrity - Ida B. Wells-Barnett - Google Art Project - restoration crop.jpg
  42. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Kaubalaeva "E. Russ" vrakk.jpg
  43. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fireworks over Houston, Texas (LOC).jpg
  44. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Rainbow-spiral lollipop.JPG
  45. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Archbasilica of St. John Lateran HD.jpg
  46. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Still Pond 3, Isabella Plantation, Richmond Park, London, UK - Diliff.jpg
  47. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ana Ivanović - Masters de Madrid 2015 - 02.jpg
  48. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Crocodylus acutus camouflage.jpg
  49. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mausoleum of Galla Placidia ceiling mosaics.jpg
  50. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Paeonia rockii 2015 G1.jpg
  51. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Church of Santi Nereo e Achilleo.jpg
  52. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Monticelli (Rome) - interior.jpg
  53. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2012 Olbrachcice, Kościół Świętych Apostołów Piotra i Pawła 05.jpg
  54. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2015 Góry Złote z Borówkowej 01.jpg
  55. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Komargorod pond 2013 G3.jpg
  56. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Apse mosaic - Basilica of San Vitale (Ravenna).jpg
  57. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dehrn Lahnbrücke02circcropedit 2011-05-21.jpg/2
  58. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Parelstuifzwam (Lycoperdon perlatum). Locatie, Hortus (Haren, Groningen) 10.JPG
  59. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Newag Impuls (31WE-004A) - Wrocław (Breslau).JPG
  60. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Berdorf (LU), Schiessentümpel -- 2015 -- 6033.jpg
  61. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fresco of hall of Apollo in Villa d'Este (Tivoli).jpg
  62. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Snowy road Sosonka 2013 G1.jpg
  63. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Cranes made by Origami paper.jpg
  64. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fountain water droplets.jpg
  65. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Frans Post - Gezicht op Olinda, Brazilië.jpg/3
  66. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Nysa, Dom Wagi Miejskiej 13.JPG
  67. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Carnitas in Mexico.jpg
  68. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Crisogono (Rome) - Interior.jpg
  69. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jim Morrison 1967.jpg
  70. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Halobaena caerulea in flight - SE Tasmania.jpg
  71. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2013 Australian Open - Guillaume Rufin.jpg
  72. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of church in Palazzo Farnese (Caprarola).jpg
  73. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ágnes Szávay at the 2009 French Open 1.jpg
  74. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Saint Peter's Basilica at sunset.jpg
  75. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2010 Malaysian GP opening lap.jpg
  76. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Spechtensee gegen Nordosten 01.JPG
  77. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:15-06-12-Himmelsstürmer-Kassel-N3S 7924.jpg
  78. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Siegestor Munich at Dusk 2.JPG
  79. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2010 Malaysian GP opening lap.jpg
  80. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Osmussaar. Lighthouse..jpg
  81. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Zgromadzenie Sióstr św. Elżbiety w Nysie 05.jpg
  82. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Cesareo de Appia (Rome) ,interior.jpg
  83. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Spot-billed duck, Nagai Park.jpg
  84. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:GP Camión de España 2013 - 01.jpg
  85. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sky team - 1st stage Tour of Slovenia 2015.jpg
  86. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Smogorówka Dolistowska - rainbow.JPG
  87. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Andrea della Valle (Roma) - Dome.jpg
  88. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Kamienny-falochron Sarbinowo.jpg
  89. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Frans Post - Gezicht op Olinda, Brazilië.jpg/4
  90. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Safety Car side 2015 Malaysia.jpg
  91. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Col Aubisque.jpg
  92. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gevlekte orchis (Dactylorhiza maculata). Locatie. Nationaal Park Lauwersmeer 02.jpg
  93. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of Church of the Gesù (Rome).jpg
  94. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Red rose with black background.jpg
  95. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The Apotheosis of St. Dominic.jpg
  96. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Externsteine High Resolution v2 2015.jpg
  97. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Brown-eared bulbuls perching on the cables.jpg
  98. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jules Bianchi Marussia 2013 Silverstone F1 Test 002.jpg
  99. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bolma persica 01.JPG
  100. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Norra Kvill National Park, Sweden (by Pudelek).jpg
  101. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of Santa Maria di Loreto (Rome).jpg
  102. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bee on Lavender Blossom.JPG
  103. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Morpho peleides (Kollar, 1850).jpg
  104. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Pseudothemis zonata, Keitakuen, Osaka.jpg/2
  105. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:150524 Konzerthaus Berlin (Nacht) - clone.jpg
  106. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Storebæltsforbindelsen højbroen.jpg
  107. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mausoleum of Galla Placidia mosaics.jpg
  108. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Französischer Dom, Gendarmenmarkt, Berlin (Blaue Stunde).jpg
  109. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gavião caramujeiro.jpg/2
  110. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Andrea al Quirinale - Dome.jpg
  111. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Annika Beck 2, 2015 Wimbledon Qualifying - Diliff.jpg
  112. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Men triple jump French Athletics Championships 2013 t154029.jpg
  113. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Agata dei Goti (Rome) - Interior.jpg
  114. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2015 Kostra, Góry Bardzkie, Sudety.JPG
  115. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Cathédrale Condom Choeur BLS.jpg
  116. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Vultur gryphus head (Linnaeus, 1758).jpg
  117. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Alaska Red Fox (Vulpes vulpes).jpg
  118. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Heavens Above Her.jpg
  119. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:NSG Rotwildpark Stuttgart 2014 14 Bärenschlössle.jpg
  120. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Swedish landscape near Björnlunda (by Pudelek) 01.jpg
  121. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Macaca fuscata meditation.jpg
  122. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Leegheide-nahe-Glabbacher-Bruch-2015.jpg
  123. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dülmen, Hausdülmen, Sonnenaufgang -- 2015 -- 4952.jpg
  124. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Agostino (Gubbio) - Intern.jpg
  125. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Atlantic mackerel (Scomber scombrus).jpg
  126. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Wilhelm Benque - Photograph of Ambroise Thomas.jpg
  127. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Grand Théâtre de l'Exposition. Palais des enfants.jpg
  128. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:McLaren mechanic on 2010 Canadian GP.jpg
  129. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Brixner Dom Deckenfresko Anbetung 2.JPG
  130. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lilium martagon mit Rutpela maculata 01.JPG
  131. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Münster, Torminbrücke -- 2015 -- 7447.jpg
  132. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Rozenkransje (Antennaria dioica) Locatie, Tuinreservaat Jonker vallei 06.jpg
  133. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Parque Nacional da Chapada Diamantina - Bahia - Brasil(3).jpg
  134. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Common brimstone butterfly (Gonepteryx rhamni) male.jpg
  135. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Painted ceiling of the throne room of Pope Pius VI in Rocca Abbey (Subiaco).jpg
  136. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:JuminadLoojang.jpg
  137. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Emirates Airbus A380-861 A6-EER MUC 2015 01.jpg
  138. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Henry Solomon Wellcome; three-quarter length. Oil painting Wellcome L0003723.jpg
  139. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:15-07-30-Rohloff-Speedhub-FocusStacking-RalfR-N3S 0102 3 4 5.jpg
  140. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Matanuska-Susitna Borough, Alaska.jpg
  141. Commons:Featured picture candidates/Set/Gold 20-stater of Eucratides
  142. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gilbert Duprez & Rosine Stoltz in Donizetti's La Favorite.jpg
  143. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria della Vittoria in Rome - Ceiling.jpg
  144. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Notre Dame de France Church Interior, London, UK - Diliff.jpg
  145. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lourdes Domínguez Lino 2, 2015 Wimbledon Qualifying - Diliff.jpg
  146. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Chapultepec Zoo - Jaguar (02).jpg
  147. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Charlotte Perkins Gilman c. 1900.jpg
  148. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Die Wildkatze in der Wildnis.jpg
  149. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bald eagle at the Hawk Conservancy Trust 2.jpg
  150. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bumblebee on Lavender Blossom.JPG
  151. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo alle Quattro Fontane (Rome) - Dome HDR.jpg
  152. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2014 Subaru Impreza WRC 2001 a.jpg
  153. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Anthophora montana, M, Face, Larimer Co, CO 2013-12-11-11.32.09 ZS PMax (11455947763).jpg
  154. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The central oval room of dawn.jpg
  155. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Claude Monet - Woman with a Parasol - Madame Monet and Her Son - Google Art Project.jpg
  156. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Neumagen-Dhron, Mosel -- 2015 -- 7556.jpg
  157. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:12-10-13-kongreszhalle-nuernberg-by-RalfR-01.jpg
  158. Commons:Featured picture candidates/Set/L’Afficheur
  159. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:John's Lane Church Interior 2, Dublin, Ireland - Diliff.jpg
  160. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Giuseppe Barberis - Carlo Cornaglia - Giuseppe Verdi's Don Carlo at La Scala.jpg
  161. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Caupolicana electa, f, ga, baker, side 2015-01-08-09.24.44 ZS PMax (16394012107).jpg
  162. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Ignazio (Rome) -False Dome.jpg
  163. Commons:Featured picture candidates/Set/Hudson's Soap
  164. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Editing File-El Tovar Hotel inside staircase.JPG
  165. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Luigi dei Francesi (Rome) - Ceiling HDR.jpg
  166. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ebenthal Radsberg Pfarrkirche heiliger Lambert Eingang stufenfoermiger Ueberbau 13022010 588.jpg
  167. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:South African Airways Airbus A340-313 ZS-SXE MUC 2015 02.jpg
  168. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bückeburger Festtagstracht in Kleinenbremen.jpg
  169. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Highland cattle Secëda Gherdëina.jpg
  170. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ebenthal Radsberg Pfarrkirche hl Lambert 13022010 1675.jpg
  171. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Statue of Lion in the honour Grand Staircase of the Palace of Caserta.jpg
  172. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stockholm August 2015 01.jpg
  173. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ophrys insectifera - Kärbesõis Niitvälja 1.jpg
  174. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lobatus gallus 01.JPG
  175. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Armillaria mellea, Honey Fungus, UK 1.jpg
  176. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Zayapa (Grapsus grapsus), Las Bachas, isla Santa Cruz, islas Galápagos, Ecuador, 2015-07-23, DD 30.jpg
  177. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gryllotalpa gryllotalpa 01.JPG
  178. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Incomplete Graffito.jpg
  179. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Bernardo alle Terme (Rome) - Dome HDR.jpg
  180. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mycene gold mask 1 NAMA Athens Greece.jpg
  181. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo alle Quattro Fontane (Rome) - Intern.jpg
  182. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Alexandre Lacauchie - Gilbert Duprez as Gaston in Verdi's Jérusalem.jpg
  183. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Buckwheat and products from it 01.jpg
  184. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lima Klostergang IMG 1567a.jpg
  185. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Tuam Cathedral of the Assumption Blessed Virgin Mary and the Four Evangelists by Michael O'Connor 2009 09 14.jpg
  186. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Photax BW 2015-03-01 16-45-43.jpg
  187. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Kleiber - Sitta europaea.jpg
  188. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:LEI0440 190 Leica IIIf chrom - Sn. 580566 1951-52-M39 vs. Minox Leica IIIf Ohne Blitz Version 2-6124 hf.jpg
  189. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Rometsch lawrence2.jpg
  190. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Russian Imperial Family 1913.jpg
  191. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of cappella sacripante in Sant'Ignazio (Rome) HDR.jpg
  192. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bombus cryptarum - Solidago virgaurea - Keila.jpg
  193. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dülmen, Hausdülmen, Kettbach -- 2015 -- 8499-503.jpg
  194. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Zwellende bloemknoppen van Chaenomeles x superba 'nicolina' (chinese kwee). Locatie. Tuinreservaat Jonkervallei 02.jpg
  195. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Carte du cours du Rhône de Genève à Lyon - 1787.jpg
  196. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Hirundo rustica (Linnaeus, 1758).jpg
  197. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Rhinocypha bisignata male-Kadavoor-2015-08-20-001.jpg
  198. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mealt Waterfall with Kilt Rock, Isle of Skye.jpg
  199. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:TAXI.jpg
  200. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:London Eye at sunset 2013-07-19.jpg
  201. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Skjálfandafljót at Route 1.jpg
  202. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Santa Croce in Gerusalemme (Rome).jpg
  203. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Island Escape. Sète 01.jpg
  204. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Iglesia de Santo Domingo, Lima, Perú, 2015-07-28, DD 52-54 HDR.JPG
  205. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mosaic floor opus tessellatum detail Gorgone NAMA Athens Greece.jpg
  206. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2015 Malaysian GP opening lap.jpg
  207. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Palazzo Barberini (Rome) - Borromini's staircase.jpg
  208. Commons:Featured picture candidates/Set/Ljubljana Cathedral Altar and Cupola ceiling
  209. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Macaca nemestrina (Linnaeus, 1766).jpg
  210. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Pürgg Johanneskapelle Innenraum 01.JPG
  211. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lech dl Mandl sun Mastle cun Secëda.jpg
  212. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:0 Serres Royales de Laeken (1).jpg
  213. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Chapel ceiling of Brežice castle (Slovenia).jpg
  214. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stift Altenburg Bibliothek Fresko Nordkuppel 01.JPG
  215. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Brasilia Cathedral v2.jpg
  216. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Boerderij Arpisson (2327m.) boven Gimillan in Cogne Valley (Italië). Beklemmende leegte boven de boerderij aan het eind van het dal 01.jpg
  217. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Chamarel Falls Mauritius 2.JPG
  218. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Alpine House, Kew Gardens.jpg
  219. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:13-08-31-Kochtreffen-Wien-RalfR-N3S 7849-024.jpg
  220. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Henry Clive - Sultana.jpg
  221. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Iglesia de San Pedro de los Francos, Calatayud, España, 2014-12-29, DD 056-060 HDR.JPG
  222. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:La Poupée abandonnée, par Suzanne Valadon.jpg
  223. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Beersheba, Monument to Negev Brigade, Snake 01.jpg
  224. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Uniek door eb en vloed steeds wisselend kweldergebied. Locatie, Noarderleech Provincie Friesland 18.jpg
  225. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Palazzo Barberini (Rome) - Bernini's staircase.jpg
  226. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dülmen, Alte Brennerei Löhning -- 2015 -- 8677-81.jpg
  227. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Uniek door eb en vloed steeds wisselend kweldergebied. Locatie, Noarderleech Provincie Friesland 39.jpg
  228. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Archduke Leopold Wilhelm of Austria.jpg
  229. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santissima Trinità degli Spagnoli (Rome) - Interior.jpg
  230. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Laon Cathedral Organ 01.JPG
  231. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Blad Hydrangea paniculata.JPG
  232. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Skokloster castle (by Pudelek) 2.JPG
  233. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dülmen, Wildpark -- 2015 -- 8871-7.jpg
  234. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Kunsthistorisches Museum HDR 0082.jpg
  235. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stift Altenburg Kirche Kuppelfresko 01.JPG
  236. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lasiodora parahybana 2015 G1.jpg
  237. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bloemknop wilde peen (Daucus carota). Locatie, De Kruidhof Buitenpost.jpg
  238. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The Siege of Osaka Castle.jpg
  239. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Grand staircase ceiling with Apotheosis of the Renaissance fresco (Kunsthistorischen Museum).jpg
  240. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:ANA soldier with RPG-7 in 2013-cropped.jpg
  241. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Cornaro chapel in Santa Maria della Vittoria in Rome HDR.jpg
  242. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fehmarnsundbrücke as seen from Großenbroderfähre 20140817 1.jpg
  243. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stelzenläufer (Himantopus himantopus).jpg
  244. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria della Vittoria in Rome - Interior.jpg
  245. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Olios argelasius MHNT.jpg
  246. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stained-glass Antwerp 4.jpg
  247. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Canaletto - Bucentaur's return to the pier by the Palazzo Ducale - Google Art Project.jpg
  248. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jonge sperwer (Accipiter nisus) is geringd. Locatie, Natuurterrein De Famberhorst 03.jpg
  249. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The glory of the Prince and the twelve provinces of the Kingdom.jpg
  250. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Transept of Saint Spyridon Serbian Orthodox church (Trieste).jpg
  251. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Campitelli (Rome) - Dome.jpg
  252. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Riley Racing Six, 1500 cm³, Bj. 1935 (2007-06-17).jpg
  253. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Vista de Ágreda, España, 2015-01-02, DD 021.JPG
  254. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stift Seitenstetten Marmorsaal Deckenfresko 01.JPG
  255. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Poertschach Blumeninsel Pappeln S-Ansicht 06112015 2289.jpg
  256. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sculpture of Madonna with child and St John (Kunsthistoriches Museum).jpg
  257. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Illuminated Tennōji Park and Abeno Harukas, November 2015, Osaka.jpg
  258. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Subantarktikskua01.jpg
  259. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Pseudotachea splendida - variability.jpg
  260. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Spot-billed duck at Expo’70 Commemorative Park in Osaka, November 2015 II.jpg
  261. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Albin Egger-Lienz, Die Namenlosen (1916), Heeresgeschichtliches Museum, Wien 0594-Bearbeitet.jpg
  262. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fischbussard-4.jpg
  263. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Interior of the Palace of Caserta - Palatine Chapel.jpg
  264. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The ceremony of laying the foundation stone of the Royal Palace.jpg
  265. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jamnik 05.jpg
  266. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Campilhas July 2015-1.jpg
  267. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Falu gruva (by Pudelek).JPG
  268. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stift Altenburg Kirche Innenraum 01.JPG
  269. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Croce in Gerusalemme (Rome) - interior.jpg
  270. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Overwoekerde nog levende holle Wilg (Salix). Locatie, Natuurterrein De Famberhorst 05.jpg
  271. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Macrolepiota procera 2013 G1.jpg
  272. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Scenery of Shinji pond at Expo’70 Commemorative Park in Osaka.jpg
  273. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The arms of the Bourbon family supported by Virtue.jpg
  274. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Downtown Pittsburgh from Duquesne Incline in the morning.jpg
  275. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Palazzo Barberini.jpg
  276. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Copper Mine Museum in Falun.JPG
  277. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Heinamaa Rihkama külas.jpg
  278. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Drottningholm Palace (by Pudelek) 4.jpg
  279. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Megabalanus coccopoma.jpg
  280. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Antonio in Campo Marzio - Interior HDR.jpg
  281. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gnesau Zedlitzdorf 34 ehem Kloster Karmeliterhospiz 09122015 9428.jpg
  282. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Sant'Antonio in Campo Marzio.jpg
  283. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Poertschach Halbinselpromenade Landspitz Rondeau 29122014 774.jpg
  284. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:AT 119587 Jesuitenkirche Wien Innenansicht 9043.jpg
  285. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lower Manhattan from Brooklyn May 2015 panorama.jpg
  286. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo al Corso (Rome) HDR.jpg
  287. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Two Bacchantes and a Bull (Vatican Museums) September 2015.1a.jpg
  288. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Binocular compound microscope, Carl Zeiss Jena, 1914 (6779276516).jpg
  289. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:St. Gertraud, St. Nikolaus, St. Magdalena Dreikirchen 04.JPG
  290. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:London MMB »1E6 Lightning.jpg
  291. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Panorama of Trevi fountain 2015.jpg
  292. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:7 Collection Eybl Great Britain - E. Kealey - Women of Britain say – GO.jpg
  293. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ivan Žabota - Portret starca.jpg
  294. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo al Corso (Rome) - First Left chapel ceiling.jpg
  295. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Brighton MMB 34 West Pier.jpg
  296. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Neptune Amphitrite mosaic Herculaneum.jpg
  297. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Your motherland will never forget - restoration.jpg
  298. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Rock - Cala Barques.jpg
  299. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Royal Castle in Stockholm (by Pudelek).jpg
  300. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Delosperma cooperi (Délosperma rose) - 97.jpg/2
  301. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Trésor Caelius plat.jpg
  302. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Engin Umut Akkaya - In the Lab.JPG
  303. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Narcissus poeticus Spechtensee 01.JPG
  304. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Chur Busbahnhof ext 2015.jpg
  305. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Poertschach Johannes-Brahms-Promenade Promenadenbad Rutschenturm 29122015 9896.jpg
  306. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Pühajärve sõjatamm udus.jpg
  307. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sunflower head 2015 G1.jpg
  308. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:30a Sammlung Eybl Großbritannien. Alfred Leete (1882–1933) Britons (Kitchener) wants you (Briten Kitchener braucht Euch). 1914 (Nachdruck), 74 x 50 cm. (Slg.Nr. 552).jpg
  309. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Zicht op het IJsselmeer. Locatie Mirnser Klif 02.jpg
  310. Commons:Featured picture candidates/Set/The Four Evangelists
  311. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Erinaceus roumanicus 2013 G5.jpg
  312. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Salagou Lake, Liausson 10.jpg
  313. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Santa Maria Maddalena (Rome) HDR.jpg
  314. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Chata Ropička (by Pudelek).JPG
  315. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Skyline Frankfurt am Main 2015.jpg
  316. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Połonina Wetlińska - Smerek.JPG
  317. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Japanese Pied Wagtail in Sakai, Osaka, February 2016.jpg
  318. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Japanese pygmy woodpecker in Sakai, Osaka, February 2016.jpg
  319. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Radha and Krishna in the boat of love - Google Art Project.jpg
  320. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Wendell Phillips by Brady.jpg
  321. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Reflexos do Planalto.jpg
  322. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gesù e Maria (Rome) - Intern.jpg
  323. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bad Kleinkirchheim St Oswald Kirchweg 16 Pfarrkirche hl Oswald Tuerbeschlag 17092015 7572.jpg
  324. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Coprinus micaceus, Mica Inkcap.jpg
  325. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Earthworm head.svg
  326. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Traspontina (Rome) - Ceiling.jpg
  327. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Admiralty Building Central Frieze.jpg
  328. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Portugal 1729 8 Escudos.jpg
  329. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:La Piragua.ogv
  330. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Beach in Helsingør, Denmark.JPG
  331. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Klagenfurt Viktring Quellenstrasse Strom-Verbundnetz 13022010 1580.jpg
Architas and Σπάρτακος
  1. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mount Stuart House horoscope room 2018-08-25.jpg
  2. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Amrumer Windmühle (2018).jpg
  3. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lariño - Faro de Punta Insua -BT- 01.jpg
  4. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Bursa granularis 01.JPG
  5. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:2018 Stupa w Gompie Drophan Ling w Darnkowie 02.jpg
Where extra vote changed the result
  1. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and renominated 2018-10-10 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:G. Dury - Portrait of Dom Augusto, Duke of Leuchtenberg - Google Art Project.jpg
  2. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:File:Discobolus in National Roman Museum Palazzo Massimo alle Terme.JPG
  3. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and renominated 2018-10-13 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Leighton-Stitching the Standard.jpg
  4. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and renominated 2018-10-04 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Southern sea lion, L'Oceanogràfic (1).jpg
  5. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and post-promoted 2018-10-12 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Regent Street 01.jpg
  6. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and renominated 2018-10-06 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Stift Melk Kolomanisaal Deckenfresko 02.JPG
  7. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and renominated 2018-10-04 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fireworks over Houston, Texas (LOC).jpg
  8. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and post-promoted 2018-10-12 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Crocodylus acutus camouflage.jpg
  9. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fresco of hall of Apollo in Villa d'Este (Tivoli).jpg
  10. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and post-promoted 2018-10-12 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Carnitas in Mexico.jpg
  11. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Spechtensee gegen Nordosten 01.JPG
  12. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Smogorówka Dolistowska - rainbow.JPG
  13. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Mausoleum of Galla Placidia mosaics.jpg
  14. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Giuseppe Barberis - Carlo Cornaglia - Giuseppe Verdi's Don Carlo at La Scala.jpg
  15. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and post-promoted 2018-10-12 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Caupolicana electa, f, ga, baker, side 2015-01-08-09.24.44 ZS PMax (16394012107).jpg
  16. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Alexandre Lacauchie - Gilbert Duprez as Gaston in Verdi's Jérusalem.jpg
  17. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Lima Klostergang IMG 1567a.jpg
  18. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and renominated 2018-10-04 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Carte du cours du Rhône de Genève à Lyon - 1787.jpg
  19. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:0 Serres Royales de Laeken (1).jpg
  20. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Alpine House, Kew Gardens.jpg
  21. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Uniek door eb en vloed steeds wisselend kweldergebied. Locatie, Noarderleech Provincie Friesland 39.jpg
  22. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jonge sperwer (Accipiter nisus) is geringd. Locatie, Natuurterrein De Famberhorst 03.jpg
  23. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Copper Mine Museum in Falun.JPG
  24. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and post-promoted 2018-10-12 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Megabalanus coccopoma.jpg
  25. Pictogram voting keep.svg fixed and post-promoted 2018-10-12 Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Engin Umut Akkaya - In the Lab.JPG
  26. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Salagou Lake, Liausson 10.jpg

Comments on lists[edit]

  • I have started to fix the affected noms and inform the nominators. The fixed noms are marked in the "Where extra vote changed the result"-list. This will take some time though. --Cart (talk) 20:26, 4 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed All the files where the vote was changed due to an extra vote have now been fixed and nominators notified. Well, I didn't see the need to notify Livio about his two noms. I think it would only be a waste of time to go through all the other nominations just to strike one vote when nothing will be changed. We can use that time and energy for something better. I would like to thank Colin who made the original lists and Yann who put together the list that made it easier for me to fix this. I think it's good to wait a few days and see what the consensus will be regarding the perhaps-to-be-promoted images. I'll take care of those later. --Cart (talk) 19:15, 5 October 2018 (UTC)

What to do about the images that could be promoted after losing one vote[edit]

  • Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment I suggest that FPC that were affected by the votes, up or down, be changed automatically without having to renominate. If a photo was promoted because of double vote, unpromote, if photo was not promoted because of double vote, promote. --Tomascastelazo (talk) 04:17, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment I agree to Tomascastelazo - would be fair to handle both cases in the same way --Uoaei1 (talk) 06:35, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
  • I think it is better to renominate these images. Some may pass, and some may not pass, but then we will have a clean vote. That's what usually happens in real life elections (well how it should happen IMHO). Regards, Yann (talk) 08:21, 5 October 2018 (UTC)

Pictogram voting comment.svg Comment Cart, Yann, I agree with above. Nominations that just failed because of the extra oppose should be promoted without doubt. For example Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Regent Street 01.jpg by User:Benh. However, I'm not sure the best way to handle POTY considerations, because Benh's photo deserves a place. If you think it is tidiest to run a renom, can we make it clear that the image did deserve to be promoted earlier, but wasn't due to cheating. I also think that if anyone's nom remains a close-fail after removing a sock oppose, then I'd be happy to see a renomination. -- Colin (talk) 08:19, 5 October 2018 (UTC)

  • @Colin: I have no problem with promoting the photos if that is the consensus of the community. POTY and all of that is no problem. They can be inserted in this month's chronological and run in this year's voting. Last year we had several FPs that didn't appear in the system due to fumbles in closing the noms by PumpkinSky, and I fixed that then. I can get the photos in the right places in the system to make it all work.
I think an elegant solution to this would be to promote the photos automatically UNLESS the nominator want to re-nominate the photo now and get a clean voting session. The photos in question are:
--Cart (talk) 09:25, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
Agree. -- Colin (talk) 09:33, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
+1 -- KTC (talk) 09:38, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
I would agree. Not that I want my photo promoted (I have now left), but clearly Livio disrupted the process in those cases. - Benh (talk) 10:10, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
I am quite uneasy with promoting these images without a new vote. Regards, Yann (talk) 11:32, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Yann: If the consensus is to promote these images instead of a new vote, you can nominate them for deletion later if you don't think they are up to standard. There are always options. --Cart (talk) 11:43, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
  • The photos failed at that specific moment and would have otherwise been promoted if it weren´t for the cheating, and reflected at that time the general preferences of the community. If they are renominated now that may not pass because the make up of the community has changed. It is not that I want my images to be FP, but rather I think it is important to allow the will of the majority at that time. I would not renominate anyway. --Tomascastelazo (talk) 17:48, 5 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting info.svg Info It's been one week since the last post in this discussion, so I'll get on with fixing the promotions for these nominations. Except for File:Fireworks over Houston, Texas (LOC).jpg that has already been re-nominated. --Cart (talk) 15:46, 12 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting info.svg More info The files have now been fixed, pics inserted in galleries, users notified and photos added to chronological so they can be part of this year's POTY instead of the one they missed. I have added them to the last completed month, September, so as not to disturb the Bot counter for the current month. We don't need any more trouble right now. ('Ping' KTC to let them know what's going on since they have done the rest of the editing on that page.) --Cart (talk) 19:25, 12 October 2018 (UTC)

Cheating on own nomination of own photo[edit]

Not Featured
  1. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Saint Peter's Basilica at sunset.jpg
  2. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Intern of St. George in Locorotondo.jpg
  3. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Bernardo alle Terme - ceiling.jpg
  4. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Symbol and statues in St. Peter.jpg/2
  5. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Jesus Christ of Gian Lorenzo Bernini in San Sebastiano fuori le mura (Rome).jpg
  6. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Painted ceiling of the throne room of Pope Pius VI in Rocca Abbey (Subiaco).jpg
  7. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Statue of Lion in the honour Grand Staircase of the Palace of Caserta.jpg
  8. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo alle Quattro Fontane (Rome) - Intern.jpg
  9. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of cappella sacripante in Sant'Ignazio (Rome) HDR.jpg
  10. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Santa Croce in Gerusalemme (Rome).jpg
  11. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Palazzo Barberini (Rome) - Borromini's staircase.jpg
  12. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Palazzo Barberini (Rome) - Bernini's staircase.jpg
  13. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Interior of the Palace of Caserta - Palatine Chapel.jpg
  14. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo al Corso (Rome) HDR.jpg
  15. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Panorama of Trevi fountain 2015.jpg
  16. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo al Corso (Rome) - First Left chapel ceiling.jpg
  17. Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Croce in Gerusalemme (Rome) - interior.jpg
Featured
  1. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Andrea della Valle (Roma) - Dome.jpg
  2. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Cesareo de Appia (Rome) ,interior.jpg
  3. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Crisogono (Rome) - Interior.jpg
  4. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Fresco of hall of Apollo in Villa d'Este (Tivoli).jpg
  5. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Monticelli (Rome) - interior.jpg
  6. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Church of Santi Nereo e Achilleo.jpg
  7. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Archbasilica of St. John Lateran HD.jpg
  8. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ascension of Jesus among the apostles and the Virgin.jpg
  9. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Trastevere - Chapel ceiling.jpg
  10. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:File:Discobolus in National Roman Museum Palazzo Massimo alle Terme.JPG
  11. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Intern of Church of San Francesco in Amelia.jpg
  12. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Concattedrale of Sutri - intern.jpg
  13. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of Church of the Gesù (Rome).jpg
  14. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The Apotheosis of St. Dominic.jpg
  15. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Dome of Santa Maria di Loreto (Rome).jpg
  16. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Andrea al Quirinale - Dome.jpg
  17. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Agata dei Goti (Rome) - Interior.jpg
  18. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Agostino (Gubbio) - Intern.jpg
  19. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria della Vittoria in Rome - Ceiling.jpg
  20. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Carlo alle Quattro Fontane (Rome) - Dome HDR.jpg
  21. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The central oval room of dawn.jpg
  22. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Ignazio (Rome) -False Dome.jpg
  23. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Luigi dei Francesi (Rome) - Ceiling HDR.jpg
  24. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:San Bernardo alle Terme (Rome) - Dome HDR.jpg
  25. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santissima Trinità degli Spagnoli (Rome) - Interior.jpg
  26. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Cornaro chapel in Santa Maria della Vittoria in Rome HDR.jpg
  27. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria della Vittoria in Rome - Interior.jpg
  28. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The glory of the Prince and the twelve provinces of the Kingdom.jpg
  29. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Campitelli (Rome) - Dome.jpg
  30. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The ceremony of laying the foundation stone of the Royal Palace.jpg
  31. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:The arms of the Bourbon family supported by Virtue.jpg
  32. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Palazzo Barberini.jpg
  33. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Sant'Antonio in Campo Marzio - Interior HDR.jpg
  34. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Sant'Antonio in Campo Marzio.jpg
  35. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Ceiling of Santa Maria Maddalena (Rome) HDR.jpg
  36. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Gesù e Maria (Rome) - Intern.jpg
  37. Pictogram voting keep.svg Fixed Commons:Featured picture candidates/File:Santa Maria in Traspontina (Rome) - Ceiling.jpg

Action to be taken[edit]


On it[edit]

  • Ok, I'll get on with fixing these as I did with the rest. I'll mark in the list as they get done. --Cart (talk) 10:20, 18 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Pictogram voting keep.svg All fixed. Hopefully it will be a long time before we have to go through someting like this again. --Cart (talk) 15:26, 18 October 2018 (UTC)
  • Thanks very much Cart. Agree, two sock cheats this year is two sock cheats too many. -- Colin (talk) 07:04, 19 October 2018 (UTC)

Extra images disrupting the FPC closing process[edit]

Another reminder that you should please not display extra images in FPC nominations unless they are Alternatives. The Bot will read them as Alts as soon as they are not written like this: [[:File:Nice photo.jpg]]. This time it was Ralf Roletschek who has added a small eye to his signature. This will be read as an Alt every time he votes at FPC, so please Ralf remove it from your signature. This is how the Bot closing looked: [7]. We have had this trouble before, and the only way is to close the nom as if it had an Alt: [8]. For everyone's sake, no extra images. In addition to the reason above, images in signatures are not allowed per the official Commons policy. --Cart (talk) 22:32, 6 October 2018 (UTC)

Template:FPD[edit]

{{FPD}} says, that "only two active nominations per user are allowed". Why, for example Cart (and I think a lot of more users), nominated more pictures. I think I unstand something wrong. Please correct this. Habitator terrae 🌍 12:42, 17 October 2018 (UTC)

Hi, Right now, I don't see more than 2 active nominations for anyone. The important point is that only active nominations are counted. Withdrawn or closed nominations are not. Regards, Yann (talk) 12:59, 17 October 2018 (UTC)
The text in the template isn't really clear about this, because it doesn't define, what active means. I think it should be replaced with open, because I first thing active means, that the person must active nominate, not only upload, the picture. Habitator terrae 🌍 13:15, 17 October 2018 (UTC)
I don't understand what you mean by "the person must active nominate, not only upload, the picture". Uploading (and creating) an image is quite irrelevant to the "two" count. The rules state "Only two active nominations by the same user (that is, nominations under review and not yet closed) are allowed". It is clearly talking about the user making nominations, not about who the photographer or uploader was. I don't think "open" is any clearer than "active": both are rather terse language. More explicitly, the nomination is being "actively considered" or the nomination is "open for voting", but I don't see much need to change the text if it isn't causing widespread confusion. -- Colin (talk) 13:47, 17 October 2018 (UTC)
I'm for open for voting, because not all person could speak english like a mother tongue; Not all, I think, will know, what active means here. (Yes I know my english is very badFace-wink.svg) Habitator terrae 🌍 14:17, 17 October 2018 (UTC)
Habitator terrae if English isn't your 1st language, then the rules and template should be translated into the language you use. I don't know how to ensure such pages get translated, and don't speak any other languages, but I'm sure someone else here can do it if that is the problem. Commons is multilingual. -- Colin (talk) 17:28, 17 October 2018 (UTC)
Habitator terrae, Colin: Even though Commons is multilingual, very little of the text in it is translated into other languages. Most of the minor templates are not translated. This is mostly because the code system for translations is so complicated and hard to use. I'm a translator on en-wiki and a code hacker here on COM, still I haven't been able to make sense of the translating system here. Looking at some examples, I see that the German version of Commons is uncommonly well translated, while the Swedish is a mix of sections in Swedish and English. The translated sections are often abbreviated and either missing info or have outdated info. I had to update the faulty Swedish version of the FPC rules since the translation was done in 2009 when you only needed 5 'support' votes to get a 'feature'. The French FPC page is a bit better than the Swedish, at least it is updated, and the Spanish is very brief and sketchy on the rules.
So if you really want to know what's going on, I suggest you use the English version and Google translate. Sadly. Plus ask other users for help about what different things mean. With such inadequate info for non-English-speaking users, it's no wonder we get some rather poor nominations here from time to time. If they don't see any rules on the page in their own language, how can they know... --Cart (talk) 18:38, 17 October 2018 (UTC)
I went ahead and made {{FPD}} multilingual (and made a quick translation to French). Feel free to add additional translations. Since this is using the Translate extension, it will keep in sync with the English source. I’m happy to spend time marking pages for translation and/or upgrading legacy translations to use the Translate extension, if you point me to the pages that need updates :) Hope that helps, Jean-Fred (talk) 13:32, 18 October 2018 (UTC)

┌─────────────────────────────────┘
Thank you Jean-Fred. However, when I went ahead to translate the link to Swedish, I noticed that the link in the English original was to the wrong page. (!) This is probably because it hasn't been updated while new pages and things were added on the site. I know there are lots of these small old/outdated things that haven't been fixed. I corrected it in the original and I hope it will filter out to the translated pages. Could you just check it for me and see if it's ok? --Cart (talk) 16:00, 18 October 2018 (UTC)

Good catch Cart :) I re-marked the page for translation and the change was propagated to all translations. Jean-Fred (talk) 16:43, 18 October 2018 (UTC)
Also did {{FPX}} and Commons:Featured picture candidates/guidelines. Jean-Fred (talk) 07:42, 19 October 2018 (UTC)