|This is a Wikimedia Commons user page.
If you find this page on any site other than Wikimedia Commons, you are viewing a mirror site. Be aware that the page may be outdated, and that the user this page belongs to may have no personal affiliation with any site other than Wikimedia Commons itself. The original page is located at .
More information is available at the community portal. You may ask questions at the help desk, village pump or on IRC channel #wikimedia-commons (webchat). You can also contact an administrator on their talk page. If you have a specific copyright question, ask at the copyright village pump.
|Item||Verdict||By||Why it was a poor decision|
|Commons:Deletion requests/File:Wana Decrypt0r screenshot.png||Delete||User:Jameslwoodward||This file is in public domain. It is a screenshot of malware and is not copyright protected in US. Ex turpi causa non oritur actio. Someone in the English Wikipedia pointed out how ridiculous would be if malware were copyright protected: Everyone infected with it would automatically become a copyright violator! Also, as I stated, if malware were eligible for any protection, antivirus companies were violators of Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which is a criminal law and does not take fair use into account. The closing admin did mention that the cited book for Ex turpi causa non oritur actio was about English law, not U.S. law. Of course, he did so to say that the claim was irrelevant, because he assumed the image's country of origin is not U.K. He was wrong. That said, U.S. also has its own Title 18 of U.S. Code, Chapter 113B which addresses malware.|
|Commons:Deletion requests/File:ACDSee logo.png||Keep||User:Yann||The file was kept on the ground that it is a simple geometric shape. It is neither simple nor a single geometric shape. In addition, the source given is fake, which is by itself, a ground for deletion.|
|Commons:Deletion requests/File:HoloLens Minecraft (15716942894).png||Keep||User:Jameslwoodward||The closing admin failed to recognize license-laundring. It was closed on the grounds that "Microsoft owns Mojang and, therefore, Minecraft. As a general rule, a corporation does not need to prove that it has the right to license material from a wholly owned subsidiary". Perhaps so, but:
Fortunately, this mistake was later corrected in Commons:Deletion requests/Files in Category:Files from Microsoft Sweden.
|Commons:Deletion requests/File:Google Chrome Screenshot.png||Keep||User:Josve05a and User:Daphne Lantier||Screenshot of a non-free app is kept! Josve05a has commented "it is not original nough [sic] not to be considered close enough to the "normal" Windows toolbars and window frames." Problem: "Normal" Windows toolbars and window frames are copyright-protected. The toolbar icons alone are copyright-protected, let alone the layout that holds three such icons.|
|Commons:Deletion requests/File:Google Chrome Screenshot.png again!||Keep, again||User:Jon Kolbert||I cited both the copyright laws to show that the outcome of previous nomination is wrong. I also cited Commons:Deletion requests/File:Chrome in Windows 7.png to show that deletion has precedence. Jon Kolbert was simply uninterested in reading what I said.|