File talk:South Russia (1919–1920).png

来自Wikimedia Commons
跳转到导航 跳转到搜索

Original research?

[编辑]

@Wario2: Do you have a source for this map, or is it entirely your original work? I ask because I've noticed a number of errors in it:

  1. The map prominently displays a "Free Territory" in southeastern Ukraine. As has been discussed previously, the term "Free Territory" has no historical basis and actually originated on Wikipedia in a case of citogenesis.
  2. This map displays Dagestan as a polity, and seems to also imply that Chechnya and Ingushetia were also independent, despite all of these territories being united as part of the Wikipedia:Mountainous Republic of the Northern Caucasus.
  3. The Russian Soviet Republic is labelled simply as "Bolsheviks", which is simplistic at best.
  4. Kharkiv (Kharkov) is spelled incorrectly as "Kharkhov".

Would you be able to rectify these issues? Cheers. -- Grnrchst (留言) 15:33, 2 November 2022 (UTC)[回复]

Hello, just been busy lately but I've managed to fix that; I hadn't seen that discussion (about Makhnovshchina), and I don't know how I missed the MRNC lol; thanks for pointing out those mistakes Wario2 (留言) 19:58, 1 January 2023 (UTC)[回复]