User:Aristeas/check

FPs last edited by an IP

Motivation: I want to find out whether it makes sense to inspect our FPs regularly for anonymous edits (IP edits) because a reasonable amount of these edits is problematic (vandalism, damages, etc.). Here I have listed all FPs which were last edited by an IP (as on 2024-03-21). Checking some of them and noting down the results will allow us to conclude whether regular inspections are necessary or not.

Preliminary results: After checking all files listed here the results confirm that checking IP edits is very important – some IP edits are valid and helpful, some others are harmless, but many IP edits are nonsensical, destructive or clear vandalism. Some exemplary examples:

• File:Grey squirrel (Sciurus carolinensis) 02.jpg: Even blatant vandalism is often not noticed soon.
• File:Bohinjsko jezero 2.jpg: This addition of a nonsense text in the wrong place went unnoticed for more than 10 years.
• File:Blue_Hour_at_Pakistan_Monument.jpg: Shows that small destructive IP edits mostly go unnoticed and hence are never reverted (history). The nonsense text “Lp00” was for 1.5 years right at the beginning of the description page … and nobody noticed it.

Many thanks to Cart for helping me much with this task!

0–9

• 
   Done Reverted questionable edit
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  [No] The changed license should be checked
• 
   Done Many problematic IP edits, already healed for the most part by the bots; reverted the last piece
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

A

• 
   Done Reverted nonsensical IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted nonsensical IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted questionable IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
  (useless IP edit, probably not worth reverting)
• 
  (useless IP edit, probably not worth reverting)
• 
   Done Reverted nonsensical IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Not sufficiently well thought-out caption added by IP; improved
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

B

• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK (and one useless older IP edit, not worth reverting)
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

C

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  [No] Is the Arabic caption OK? In translation it looks a bit weird …
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted two older destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Improved ‘depicts’ statement (incorrect value probably based on misunderstanding)

D

• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits
• 
  OK

E

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit; improved the [fr] caption
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Many strange edits by several IPs; in the end the damage is low, have improved [pt] caption and ‘depicts’
• 
   Done Reverted 3 destructive IP edits
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted several destructive IP edits; fixed the (wrong) ‘deptics’ value

F

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
•  Done Reverted vandalism

G

• 
  [No] Difficult author/license changes
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted one destrutive IP edit, improved questionable Wikidata value
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

H

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK (added category back in addition)
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

I

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

J

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edit
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

K

• 
  Semi-OK, improved
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted nonsense/vandalism
• 
  OK, improved
• 
  Semi-OK, improved
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK, if you like

L

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted questionable IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
  OK/improved
• 
   Done Reverted spam insertion by IP
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

M

• 
  OK, improved
• 
  OK, improved
• 
  OK, but IMHO too specific, improved
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted a clear case of vandalism
• 
   Done Restored better version of [en] caption, deleted by IP edit
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edit
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK, improved
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

N

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  [No] Some of the category changes must be checked by an expert
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  (OK), improved

O

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits

P

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  (OK), improved
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive IP edits
• 
  [No] The license changes need to be reviewed
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted nonsense edit
• 
  OK, improved
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  (OK), improved

R

• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted strong vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK, improved
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits by 2 IPs
• 
  OK

S

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Fixed bad edits
• 
   Done Reverted several destructive IP edits
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Fixed code
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted bad edit
• 
  OK

T

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Fixed bad edits
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted destructive edits
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism

U

• 
  OK

V

• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted bad edit
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted misunderstanding
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

W

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism

X, Y, Z

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK

Others

• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
   Done Reverted vandalism
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK
• 
  OK