Commons talk:Deletion requests/File:Diagrama de los pulmones.svg
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
What links here
[edit]
What follows is text from "Special:WhatLinksHere/File:Diagrama_de_los_pulmones.svg". I copied the text because any of these items may disappear.
I wonder if there should have been any plan to alert other users of this file that it was deprecated. It is hard for me to make sense of this. I am not sure what has already been deleted.
I am not aware of any record of where this file was used, nor of any way to get any record of that now that all links to it have been deleted.
Commons:Featured pictures/Non-photographic media/Computer-generated (file link) (← links | edit) User talk:Rastrojo (A) (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (pt) (← links | edit) Commons:Picture of the Year/2007/Results/Round 1/Image vote totals (← links | edit) User talk:Rastrojo/Archivo 1 (file link) (← links | edit) Commons:Picture of the Year/2007/Results/Round 1/Category totals (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06 (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (de) (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (nl) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06 (zh-hans) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (en) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (zh-hans) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (ru) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (it) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (es) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (ko) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (sr) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (pt) (file link) (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (zh-hant) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (nl) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (zh-hant) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (is) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (als) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (hu) (file link) (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (tr) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (be) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (pl) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (sv) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (da) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (pam) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (de) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (cs) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (fr) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (ca) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (uk) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (eo) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (ar) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (ja) (file link) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06-17 (bs) (file link) (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (pl) (← links | edit) Commons:Potd/2008-06 (eo) (← links | edit) Template:Potd/2008-06 (ro) (← links | edit) File:Diagrama de los pulmones-c2.svg (← links | edit) User:KTC/FP (← links | edit) Commons:Deletion requests/Archive/2016/12/20 (file link) (← links | edit) Commons:Deletion requests/File:Diagrama de los pulmones.svg (file link) (← links | edit) Commons:Deletion requests/Archive/2017/01/03 (file link) (← links | edit) File:Illu bronchi lungs numerical labels.jpg (← links | edit) Commons:Deletion requests/Archive/2017/01/15
Blue Rasberry (talk) 17:19, 25 January 2017 (UTC)
- As I wrote in the discussion closure, this file was not in use anymore (in main namespaces). All of the remaining uses were archives etc. Sebari – aka Srittau (talk) 19:09, 25 January 2017 (UTC)
- Srittau Is it possible to get a list of where the file was used? Would you be comfortable saying that the file's use in the archives is not significant and that no notice should be given there? I am not aware of another case of a featured picture being deleted, and am not sure if anyone outside of Commons might notice and wish for an explanation. Blue Rasberry (talk) 19:42, 25 January 2017 (UTC)
- I am comfortable with that. Files references from archives are often deleted, mostly because of rights related issues. Anyway, this is an issue that should have been raised during the DR or in a potential UnDR. The consensus of the DR leaned heavily in favor of deleting, once it wasn't in use anymore. Sebari – aka Srittau (talk) 20:16, 25 January 2017 (UTC)
- One could also make an SVG copy of the "correct" file File:Illu bronchi lungs numerical labels.jpg and upload it here. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 19:13, 26 January 2017 (UTC)
- @Srittau and Bluerasberry: Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 10:54, 31 January 2017 (UTC)
- Bluerasberry It's a tad awkward, but you can find nearly all prior uses of the deleted file through my global contributions sorted by date, scrolling down to 11 Jan 2017. All my edits that day were to remove the old file, and I didn't do anything else that day. The only other removal I know of outside en.wp was this one, by CFCF. Alternatively, you can find an approximate list by looking at the file usage of the replacement image, File:Illu_bronchi_lungs_numerical_labels.jpg, though of course that won't show any cases where that file was removed and may show new uses of that file. Adrian J. Hunter (talk) 11:31, 3 February 2017 (UTC)
- Adrian J. Hunter Thanks for this. It seems like there is will in the medical community to talk about how to better address these sorts of things in the future. A discussion is on the agenda for the upcoming wiki medical event wm2017:Programme/Wiki Project Med. I will note that without a little advance preparation then this is the kind of record keeping which we will have. Blue Rasberry (talk) 12:23, 3 February 2017 (UTC)
- Bluerasberry It's a tad awkward, but you can find nearly all prior uses of the deleted file through my global contributions sorted by date, scrolling down to 11 Jan 2017. All my edits that day were to remove the old file, and I didn't do anything else that day. The only other removal I know of outside en.wp was this one, by CFCF. Alternatively, you can find an approximate list by looking at the file usage of the replacement image, File:Illu_bronchi_lungs_numerical_labels.jpg, though of course that won't show any cases where that file was removed and may show new uses of that file. Adrian J. Hunter (talk) 11:31, 3 February 2017 (UTC)
- @Srittau and Bluerasberry: Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 10:54, 31 January 2017 (UTC)
- One could also make an SVG copy of the "correct" file File:Illu bronchi lungs numerical labels.jpg and upload it here. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 19:13, 26 January 2017 (UTC)
- I am comfortable with that. Files references from archives are often deleted, mostly because of rights related issues. Anyway, this is an issue that should have been raised during the DR or in a potential UnDR. The consensus of the DR leaned heavily in favor of deleting, once it wasn't in use anymore. Sebari – aka Srittau (talk) 20:16, 25 January 2017 (UTC)
- Srittau Is it possible to get a list of where the file was used? Would you be comfortable saying that the file's use in the archives is not significant and that no notice should be given there? I am not aware of another case of a featured picture being deleted, and am not sure if anyone outside of Commons might notice and wish for an explanation. Blue Rasberry (talk) 19:42, 25 January 2017 (UTC)
