File talk:Motorway-A1-Hex-Green.svg

Reverting to wrong image

Hi JuTa, why you keep reverting my changes to this file?

Yes, I used copy of Croatian A1 sign, because they are identical in appearance, but, conceptually, they are different signs, prescribed by two different jurisdictions -- take, for example, Latin script "A" letter and Cyrillic "А" letter. Although they appear same on the screen, they are two different code points in Unicode because semantic of usage is different. So, sign for A1 motorway in Croatia, and A1 motorway in Serbia (and in Macedonia, which uses same-looking graphic) are semantically different. They are not same symbol. Moreover, version you keep reverting to is not official sign of A1 motorway anywhere, and definitely not in Serbia, so it is wrong to use, as it would be equally wrong to use Croatian traffic sign for Serbian motorway. Ђидо (talk) 05:52, 7 May 2018 (UTC)

Hi Ђидо, when they are binary identical, it makes no sense to keep 2 kopies if it. I got asked to revert your upload here, which I did because I assmued they looking different. As this is not the case, they have to share the same file name. I renamed the file to reflect this fact now. I'll do the same with the other A-road-signs of Kroatia and Servia. regards. --JuTa 22:22, 7 May 2018 (UTC)

JuTa, name should be something country-neutral (there is Republic of Macedonia which uses same shape), and also short and easy to use. How about Motorway-A1-Hex-Green.svg or just A1-Hex-Green.svg? Ђидо (留言) 22:26, 7 May 2018 (UTC)

Good idea, I'll rename it again. CommonsDelinker will do the rest. --JuTa 22:31, 7 May 2018 (UTC)

Note 'Hex' referring to hexagonal shape inside the shield. It is relevant as there are other A1 signs with different shapes. Ђидо (留言) 22:32, 7 May 2018 (UTC)