File talk:MentuhotepII.jpg

Image was nominated for deletion but kept. A copy of the debate follows:

この削除論議は終了しました。 このアーカイブに編集を加えないで下さい。 あなたは、削除の方針を読むことができ、また井戸端にて質問することができます。 このファイルに関する状況が大きく変化した場合は、再度の削除依頼か削除撤回依頼をしてもかまいません。

Image:MentuhotepII.jpg

seems not free, because it is newer photo of an relief and author has given no approval - Sven-steffen arndt 11:18, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

• Is the the third dimension (depth) of a relief significant enough that photographs have to be licensed separately? It seems to me this should be considered essentially equivalent to a 2D artwork, meaning that {{GFDL}} is the wrong tag, instead it should be {{PD-old}} or {{PD-art}}. Angr 12:02, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

Delete, since it is a photo of a three dimensional work it is not just a reproduction but a separate work.--Wiggum 14:11, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

• It doesn't seem to be a picture of a relief but of a mural; which I'd consider to be 2-D. So keep, I'd say

---

• Kept; no original authorship. / Fred Chess 13:12, 9 October 2006 (UTC)