Category talk:Villa Spineda Loredan
Title
[edit]I moved the category from Category:Villa Spineda (Venegazzù, Volpago del Montello) to Category:Villa Spineda Loredan because I tought it was the complete name, but the title is not correct yet. As I can read in
- https://www.touringclub.it
- https://www.museionline.info
- https://www.cavalliinvilla.it
- https://www.proprieta.intesasanpaolo
the complete name is Villa Spineda Gasparini Loredan, so the also the category should be Category:Villa Spineda Gasparini Loredan. As I can see in such cases in Category:Villas in the province of Treviso, for example Category:Villa Corner della Regina or Category:Villa Costantini Morosini Papadopoli-Aldobrandini or Category:Villa Manfrin detta Margherita and so on, it seemes is not mandatory to add the location, I mean Category:Villa Spineda Gasparini Loredan (Venegazzù, Volpago del Montello), when there is only one villa with a specific name. MrKeefeJohn (talk) 08:35, 29 November 2023 (UTC)
- @MrKeefeJohn: I do not argue about what the sources claim, although one should also keep in mind that ancient villas also carry in their dowry all the surnames of the families who have been awarded ownership over the years, and therefore the sources often disagree. I dwell on the removal of the geographic reference from the categories altogether, which, I assure you, does not help with proper categorization when you find an image orphaned or categorized only aproximately. In conclusion, I think it is more useful to move to Category:Villa Spineda Loredan (Venegazzù, Volpago del Montello) and please keep that in mind for any categories you move in the future as well, thank you for understanding.--Threecharlie (talk) 11:19, 29 November 2023 (UTC)