File talk:Coat of Arms of the First Slovak Republic.svg

Revert contour

The both references shows clear a contour, small but it is. The previous discussion is here.-- Perhelion (talk) 13:53, 4 May 2013 (UTC)

Colours

If the source given on the page got it right the colours chosen by Poznaniak in 2013 are a better match. If that's not the case please note your, hm, "inspirations" (?) here. Edit wars about obscure CoAs are slightly odd, and smaller than Sarang's version would be hard, don't try. –Be..anyone (留言) 20:26, 30 March 2015 (UTC)

It's a shame, more it's me not allowed to say. The color on the ref is not reputativ, that is bleached paper color. PS: With all due respect, why you/someone add some people as author they only change a color or remove a stroke? It's a shame... ↔ User: Perhelion (Commons: = crap?)  01:42, 31 March 2015 (UTC)

Authors found by me:

1st Arvedui89; 2nd Perhelion, Poznaniak, ever and ever again Fry1989

Authors left by me:

Arvedui89, Perhelion, Poznaniak, Fry1989, Sarang

I've only added Sarang, because his 745 bytes isn't the same as your 795 bytes, or the 3 KB version. I've not downloaded the older versions to check what exactly the differences were, the current version is valid and the smallest. –Be..anyone (留言) 00:36, 8 April 2015 (UTC)

Ok we need a definition, what is an author!? But there is nothing on Commons, with exception the template Information himself?!? Slightly code opt (which was also me), one slightly color change, remove something (especially what was removed before) makes not a new author. So I propose to remove 2 authors (you and Sarang have added, that means not that I not appreciate your attention here.). I've nothing more to say here (because of an block for all this rubbish here). Best Regards and Good Bye ↔ User: Perhelion (Commons: = crap?)  09:33, 8 April 2015 (UTC)

"Getting the credits right"  is something I consider as important on one level with "this is a wiki, SoFixIt if I got it nevertheless wrong". If this talk page is unsuited for a discussion because you can't say what you want to say move the thread to a better place, ideally still in reach for the other co-authors if they want to chime in.

From my POV upload, revert, minor bug fixes, or brute force load+save attacks with "scour", "librsvg-convert", "svgedit", etc. SHOULD NOT be listed as coauthors. Unless there are compelling obvious reasons to do it, e.g., if the co-authors already list any change—I'd stick to the style as found. Likewise minor colour, font, or text changes also aren't co-authors, but major clean-ups consisting of several minor changes MAY be noted. –Be..anyone (留言) 15:36, 8 April 2015 (UTC)