Data talk:Kuala Lumpur Districts.map

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Created to raise DR. -- (talk) 10:44, 12 October 2017 (UTC)

Strong oppose. The uploader states that OSM was not used, and any reference to OSM has been removed from the files. Indeed, OSM copyright would only hold if the whole map boundaries were extracted from OSM and pasted into the Data file on Commons. This was not the case, because all maps in question depict Wikivoyage districts, which are invented and decided upon by the Wikivoyage community. Such district boundaries do not exist at OSM. Therefore, they are essentially drawn by hand. The author might have perused OSM as well as other maps when drawing the district boundaries, but none of the boundaries are taken from any external source.
@Ymblanter, WhatamIdoing. --Alexander (talk) 12:15, 12 October 2017 (UTC)

Please make any comments or keep/delete opinions in the DR rather than here. Thanks -- (talk) 13:21, 12 October 2017 (UTC)

Sample Open Street Map coordinates in this data file[edit]

  1. Data:(101.6596906, 3.1145888) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580464
  2. Data:(101.6526728, 3.1101407) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887001
  3. Data:(101.6508811, 3.1149401) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887002
  4. Data:(101.6505271, 3.1157864) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887003
  5. Data:(101.6501408, 3.1165042) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887005
  6. Data:(101.6498404, 3.1170184) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887007
  7. Data:(101.6494864, 3.1174684) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887009
  8. Data:(101.6492074, 3.1177469) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887011
  9. Data:(101.6488641, 3.1179933) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887013
  10. Data:(101.6484564, 3.1181754) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887015
  11. Data:(101.6478878, 3.1183575) Source:Cicerone 2010-06-18 OSM node:775887017
  12. Data:(101.6473941, 3.1184553) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580467
  13. Data:(101.6453069, 3.1185693) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580469
  14. Data:(101.6438385, 3.1186575) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957600
  15. Data:(101.6437116, 3.1187534) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580471
  16. Data:(101.6435863, 3.1188731) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957599
  17. Data:(101.6434643, 3.1190632) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957598
  18. Data:(101.6434241, 3.1196016) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957597
  19. Data:(101.6434965, 3.1201506) Source:MAPconcierge 2015-07-09 OSM node:3641957601
  20. Data:(101.6441065, 3.1208351) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580475
  21. Data:(101.6481066, 3.1250671) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580477
  22. Data:(101.6483615, 3.1260753) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580478
  23. Data:(101.6481373, 3.126654) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580479
  24. Data:(101.647883, 3.1272514) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580480
  25. Data:(101.6470491, 3.1282235) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580485
  26. Data:(101.6464341, 3.1277216) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580483
  27. Data:(101.6457262, 3.1275397) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580482
  28. Data:(101.6446912, 3.1275108) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580481
  29. Data:(101.6437713, 3.1277758) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580484
  30. Data:(101.6403895, 3.1295851) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580487
  31. Data:(101.6385446, 3.1303833) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580488
  32. Data:(101.6371602, 3.131462) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580492
  33. Data:(101.6366216, 3.1318186) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580494
  34. Data:(101.6361197, 3.1320682) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580496
  35. Data:(101.6348734, 3.1323485) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580497
  36. Data:(101.6317081, 3.1316348) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580493
  37. Data:(101.630369, 3.1306962) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580491
  38. Data:(101.6300031, 3.1306056) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580490
  39. Data:(101.6294992, 3.1305895) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580489
  40. Data:(101.6292746, 3.1326296) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580498
  41. Data:(101.6296214, 3.1351764) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580501
  42. Data:(101.6296007, 3.136808) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580503
  43. Data:(101.629104, 3.1373507) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580504
  44. Data:(101.628069, 3.138012) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580506
  45. Data:(101.6271544, 3.1394086) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580507
  46. Data:(101.6261565, 3.1409386) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580508
  47. Data:(101.6253218, 3.1415494) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580511
  48. Data:(101.6248359, 3.1415503) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580510
  49. Data:(101.6233233, 3.1413027) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580509
  50. Data:(101.6213231, 3.1433364) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580513
  51. Data:(101.6199551, 3.1447125) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580514
  52. Data:(101.6192281, 3.1458206) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580516
  53. Data:(101.6187211, 3.1469526) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580518
  54. Data:(101.6173808, 3.1492228) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580520
  55. Data:(101.6164905, 3.1506222) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580522
  56. Data:(101.6151785, 3.152866) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580525
  57. Data:(101.615081, 3.1534803) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580527
  58. Data:(101.6152677, 3.158678) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580531
  59. Data:(101.6156169, 3.1607388) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580532
  60. Data:(101.6163601, 3.161347) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580535
  61. Data:(101.6165536, 3.1633401) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580539
  62. Data:(101.6160501, 3.1644449) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580540
  63. Data:(101.6161834, 3.1657988) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580543
  64. Data:(101.6165338, 3.1675584) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580544
  65. Data:(101.6166459, 3.168471) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580545
  66. Data:(101.6167597, 3.1701578) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580546
  67. Data:(101.6178152, 3.1710006) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580547
  68. Data:(101.6190405, 3.1740359) Source:mahau 2013-05-30 OSM node:2325070012
  69. Data:(101.6191681, 3.1821202) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580565
  70. Data:(101.619557, 3.1857576) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580570
  71. Data:(101.6198848, 3.1883939) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580573
  72. Data:(101.6190204, 3.1938579) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580577
  73. Data:(101.6188589, 3.195483) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580578
  74. Data:(101.6188486, 3.1962285) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580579
  75. Data:(101.6191165, 3.1979053) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580584
  76. Data:(101.6202478, 3.1974894) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580581
  77. Data:(101.6218987, 3.1975594) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580582
  78. Data:(101.6230345, 3.197846) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580583
  79. Data:(101.6239211, 3.198324) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580585
  80. Data:(101.6251656, 3.1995411) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580586
  81. Data:(101.6262049, 3.2011251) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580589
  82. Data:(101.6276245, 3.2036909) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580592
  83. Data:(101.6294006, 3.2085925) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580595
  84. Data:(101.6596906, 3.1145888) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580464
  85. Data:(101.6294006, 3.2085925) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580595
  86. Data:(101.6374012, 3.2320994) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580645
  87. Data:(101.6460737, 3.2321642) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580646
  88. Data:(101.6462036, 3.2335911) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580653
  89. Data:(101.6504911, 3.2337208) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580654
  90. Data:(101.654064, 3.234337) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580655
  91. Data:(101.6540965, 3.2368665) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580658
  92. Data:(101.6573446, 3.2360233) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580656
  93. Data:(101.6572471, 3.2372556) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580659
  94. Data:(101.6577993, 3.2413093) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580662
  95. Data:(101.659261, 3.2414066) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580663
  96. Data:(101.6611449, 3.2405958) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580660
  97. Data:(101.6611124, 3.2425416) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580664
  98. Data:(101.6635809, 3.2443252) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580666
  99. Data:(101.6659845, 3.2431901) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580665
  100. Data:(101.6682907, 3.2406931) Source:mahau 2013-05-17 OSM node:2307580661

Many of the above nodes are sourced on OSM as "Gov. MY". The source website http://www.data.gov.my/ releases map data under terms at http://www.data.gov.my/page/termsofuse. The terms include the requirement to link back to the terms and give an attribution. Consequently any map derived from the data cannot be CC0. -- (talk) 11:58, 20 October 2017 (UTC)