User:Shyamal

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

English Wikipedia User page

Userboxes
VG-4
AF-4
  • Summary as of 25 December 2018 - User "Shyamal" has 15260 files (54.32% in use).
Site Images used
en.wikipedia 15016
fr.wikipedia 9379
vi.wikipedia 8987
cy.wikipedia 7225
it.wikipedia 4572
sv.wikipedia 4402
pt.wikipedia 4367
wikidata.wikipedia 4225
ceb.wikipedia 3994
nl.wikipedia 3078
es.wikipedia 2568
eu.wikipedia 2187
war.wikipedia 2067
de.wikipedia 1972
ca.wikipedia 1776
species.wikipedia 1599
ru.wikipedia 1543
pl.wikipedia 1489
bg.wikipedia 1212
zh.wikipedia 1175
ja.wikipedia 1129
fa.wikipedia 1118
no.wikipedia 1022
Total image usages 104344
Distinct images used 8289

My approach[edit]

Please note that I do not and will not attempt to classify images to all possible and existing categories or by adding them to pages. I however ensure that they belong to at least one suitable category and include the description which has the keywords needed for a searcher to find the image. In all likelihood the image will also be in use on a relevant page on the English wikipedia.

It is particularly unfortunate that Commons has a completely chaotic system of categories. For instance there is "Category:Bird family Y" and "category:Birds of Location X" and then there are passing users who create "category:Birds of Location X belong to family Y" - this is clearly non-scaleable. I think temporal, geographic, conceptual classes need to be kept apart and no combinations should be made (eg:prefer India, 1887 as two categories rather than India in 1887). Categories should be "atomic" - similar to Codd's rule.

I believe that spatial categories, especially those used for organisms, should not be done with named entities or textual labels - we ought to have either points, bounding rects or polygons and all searches some polygons and points can be mapped to names on Wikidata so that spatial search on commons is meaningful.

Note to compulsive category hierarchy maintainers: Some categories like "unidentified insects of xxx" are not at all useful when insects (or other such groups) are already identified to genus - chances of identifying them to species are almost zilch.

Postscript - see Commons_talk:Structured_data

Mediawiki feature wishlist[edit]

SVGs with within commons image linking ability - SVG has a feature to link raster images in it - Mediawiki would do well to allow images from commons to be linked. This would allow annotation, clipping and some nice features. The rsvg rasterizer however may need to support this further. Even better would be a Commons- online SVG editor to produce some of these annotated images. It might however raise some legal eyebrows in some contexts:- we allow some copyrighted content as part of freedom of panorama and using a clip region to isolate the copyrightable part could lead to some hitherto unheard of legal issues.

Note that "virtual" clipping is now possible via en:Template:CSS_image_crop

Bookmark[edit]

Done till

  • Ibis 1922
  • PZSL 1903 2

Tools to use[edit]